What skills are needed for effective golf coaching? I think this is an excellent question. I also think that the answers will vary widely across the industry. Maybe not in terms of what those skills should/could be but in what proportion they should be in. This post will not pretend to serve as an answer to this question but hopefully will continue the discussion that is constantly ongoing within our field.
So, let’s start with a list, in no particular order. I’m going to leave out all the buzzwords like creativity, passion and all that stuff related to sounding appropriate. Just the hard skills for now. Not saying those other things aren’t needed but not really sure I would classify them as skills.
1) Knowledge and understanding of golf swing theory, including short game, putting and everything that includes
2) Communication
3) How to play the game/The ability to compete and demonstrate
4) Mental strength/Process
Ok, so this list doesn’t seem so big yet these categories are huge and can encompass many subcategories. Based on my experience, the only skill that creates debate on whether or not it is a necessary skill is number 3. How important is skill #3 in being an effective golf coach? Remember when thinking of your answer that the question relates directly to golf coaching. I hear all the time how in other sports the coach wasn’t a player so it shouldn’t be necessary in golf.
I struggle with this question. As a coach that didn’t compete at a very high level (just PGA section events), I feel as if I am missing something when it comes to providing help for dealing with on course situations that the high level player encounters. I’m not sure if this feeling is accurate or not but it’s just how I feel. I was asking on twitter this week how people felt about a coaches playing ability and how important it is. As is typical, I heard a good mix of responses.
Here’s my take on it. Because golf is a recreational sport that doesn’t really require all that much athleticism to play, many players can get very good. Not as good as Tour level but very good just the same. Before you get all ramped up, when I say athleticism, I’m talking about the genetics that allows one to compete in speed and size based activities. Golf doesn’t really have either of those requirements to play it well. That’s not to say that those genetic traits wouldn’t be helpful because they would.
Back to my point. Because it doesn’t require certain things, the expectations of the golf coach are higher in terms of performance. I think most students expect the golf coach to be able to perform at a certain level. To be significantly better than they are, at least at the club level. How many times have you heard the recreational golfer say, “Heck, I can hit shots like that.” when they see a bad shot on TV. It’s for this reason, that I think the golf coach should be able to perform to some level. I’m not really sure what that level is though. I think it may vary depending on the level of student they teach. I’m just not sure but I want my pro to be able to do at least a certain amount of things.
Certainly, the ability of the coach will shift over time and I am quite comfortable doing this on a sliding scale. Not in terms of age, per se, but maybe in terms of life situation or something like that. For example, is it appropriate to expect a coach that is required to fold shirts and answer the phone all day to maintain his skills as well as a coach that is on the lesson tee all day, or the coach that is expected to play with their students all the time? I don’t think so but that’s just me. Even though, I think the coach should still have the ability to hit good shots. It’s the level of his/her good shots that tells me what I need to know.
As golf coaches, I also think that skill #3 is the one we, as a group, tend to put the least importance on.
So, my question to you is, how important is your golf coaches ability to play the game to you?
If you’re a coach reading this, how important do you place skill #3 in your priorities as a golf coach?
Please leave your comments and pass this on if you found some value in it.

