Virtually every lesson has multiple routes for approaching the issue. Part of becoming a great teacher is diagnosing the issue. The other part is prescribing the right ‘medicine’ to cure what ails. After that, you need to have a long term plan for where this golfer should end up if they stay with you for awhile.
For me, the real trick is blending all of these things together in the span of 30 minutes or an hour. The better I feel I become as a teacher, the more time I feel I need to help the player in these three areas.
I was taught that if you can’t fix a person in 10-15 minutes, you didn’t know what you were doing. An hour lesson is way too long because you spend most of the time watching them hit after the lesson. This all made sense so I did mainly 30 minute lessons.
Granted, there is a cost issue as well. The 30 minute lessons are cheaper and more popular yet the hour or longer lessons produce better and longer lasting results. For me, the longer lessons give me more time to see more of what they do.
Is it better to have 2 or 3 hours lessons that cover a wide array of topics or is that just too much? I continue to struggle with this one.
My main goal for writing this blog is to inform my students that I cam constantly trying to improve. Both in the factuality of the information I am giving and in the order of the information given. This second area is where I still see the greatest room for improvement.
Related posts:
John, I recall reading somwhere on your site that you were thinking of pursuing an idea of more structured practice versus formal lessons, especially for your more skilled students.Might be a good time to expand on that.
JG,
I believe in a 75 minute lesson that is given on two separate days, and is divided into a 45 minute lesson, and 2 15 minute supervised practice sessions – 1 ‘during’ the lesson and 1 roughly 3-5 days afterward.
If learning is indifferent to correctness, I want to be able to ensure that my student understands how to conduct their prescribed practice correctly. Supervising their practice facilitates this. Moreover, it helps build the relationship with the student, by helping them between lessons. I liken it to a barber that offers a ‘clean up’ before the next cut.
Cheers.
Matt
Matt,
I think that is a fantastic idea.
I certainly feel differently now then when I wrote that post. Including some supervised practice in the coaching is a super idea.
Well done.
JG