Archive for March, 2010

Trackman vs Flightscope 2

March 28th, 2010
Trackman Launch Moniter

Trackman Launch Moniter

Almost exactly a year ago, I did a blog post called Trackman vs. Flightscope where I talked about my experience with testing the two machines.  You can follow the previous link the read my initial review.  Basically, it states the Trackman is just more accurate.  This is especially true when it comes to the angle of attack.

I’d heard that Flightscope had come out with some new software and wanted to see how the two compared again.  One of my twitter followers sent me some results from a side by side comparison of the new Flightscope Prime with the new software and Trackman.

I am in the process of loading the data onto my server and will post it here when complete.  Data is located at the end of the post.

Until then, I will tell you what it shows.  For the most part, the two machines tracked the flight and launch of the ball almost exactly.

Flightscope Prime

Flightscope Prime

Some shots had variables in spin but not enough for me to say that one is worse than the other.  This test composed of a sand wedge, 6 iron and a driver.  Once again, the issue with Flightscope was the angle of attack.  Driver comparisons were pretty close but when it came to the 6 iron and sandwedge, the Flightscope was way off.  In 8 of 10 shots, Flightscope returned a positive angle of attack for a club professional.  This is just way off.

We all know that we are supposed to take a divot after the ball with an iron shot.  The only way to accomplish this is with a downward angle of attack.  Not only is the angle of attack incorrect but because it is incorrect, the club path numbers are inaccurate.   The angle of attack has a direct impact on the 3d club path.  Downward angles of attack create a more rightward path relative to the swing and upward angles of attack create a more leftward path relative to the swing.  So when Trackman says 2 degrees down and Flightscope says 2 degrees up, we have a major difference in club path.

I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again.  Flightscope would work very well as a fitting tool but if you want a fitting tool and a teaching tool you need a Trackman.  Just remember Flightscope is about $8000 and Trackman Pro is about $28000.  Accuracy is what you get for that extra $20000.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Update:  I had some questions regarding the set up of the test so here’s a picture of the set up:

Trackman vs Flightscope Set Up

Trackman vs Flightscope Set Up

Here is the Data and screen shots from the 6irons in question:

Trackman Screen Shot for 6 Iron Data

Trackman Screen Shot for 6 Iron Data

Flightscope Screen Shot for 6 Iron Data

Flightscope Screen Shot for 6 Iron Data

Here are the screen shots to show that this data is from the newest version of software and firmware that Flightscope offers:

Flightscope Firmware Version

Flightscope Firmware Version

Flightscope Software

Flightscope Software

Golf Training Aid – Tour Striker Pro

March 27th, 2010

The Tour Striker and its partner in crime Tour Striker Pro were developed by PGA Professional Martin Chuck.  I’ve spoken to Martin many times through e-mail and online forums but never tried his product.  I think he’s developed something that will really help the majority of golfers produce an impact position that anyone can be proud of.  Along with this comes more distance and consistency of flight and contact.

His invention is the Tour Striker and Tour Striker Pro.  Coming down the road is also a Tour Striker X and Tour Striker Wedge.  Here are some pictures of the Tour Striker and Tour Striker Pro.

Tour Striker and Tour Striker Pro

Tour Striker and Tour Striker Pro

Tour Striker and Tour Striker Pro from Front

Tour Striker and Tour Striker Pro from Front

You can see from the pictures that these clubs look a little different.  These clubs have the leading edge and first few scoring lines of the club beveled off as well as some of the toe.  The Tour Striker Pro is beveled a little more aggressively making it more difficult to hit well.  Why are these clubs designed this way?  The purpose of the beveling is to force the golfer to create sound impact alignments.  If the club is not in the right shape, the player will not be able to get the ball in the air.  So, what shape should the club be in when it strikes the ball?  Take a look at this picture to see:

Correct Impact Shape

Correct Impact Shape

If you didn’t know the club was supposed to look like this when it hit the ball, now you do.  The handle end should be leaning toward the target for every standard iron shot.  You can see from the above picture that only when the club is in this position does the clubface get into a position to get the ball in the air.

I used the Tour Striker Pro for the first time last week and was very impressed.  I can say that I dribbled a couple too.  I will stall my pivot every once in a while and flip the club through impact.  Whenever I did that with this club, it looked like a cold top.  Good impact alignments with good shaft lean toward the target produced good shots.  No confusing feels.  I think I did it there. Just cold hard results.  Top or flight.

I see this club as the answer to bridging the time between lessons.  If we are working on this aspect of the swing, I can be confident that the student can not fudge the results.  Produce the right shape and the ball will go.  Produce the wrong shape and the ball will not.  I would recommend, as Martin does, to practice from tight fairway lies to get the most benefit from the club.  Try it on a lie board for an even harder test.

I give the Tour Striker Pro rave reviews and will be using them in my teaching on a regular basis.

What if the ideal golf game just doesn’t exist?

March 25th, 2010

 

And so I prepare myself to be shot down in flames, which is great because it means you the reader, will be bringing new insights with you.

There’s no such thing as an ideal golf game…..daring statement to make?

Perhaps! However for me, even in a world where golf instruction worldwide promises you the IDEAL golf swing ( either in the form of following 5 simple steps, signing up to elaborate DVD or audio programmes, or indeed downloading 100+ videos ) pursuit of an ideal golf swing will forever be a false claim.

Because here’s how it seems to me until now. I’m guessing we all understand what the horizon is; that ‘line’ where sky meets land. You’ll also know that it doesn’t exist in the real world, it’s merely a mental frame set up in our heads to help us make sense of that place in the distance. If you doubt that’s true, walk to it and tell me when you get there!  These mental frames, or ‘Ideals’, are a necessary part of our thoughts which help us make sense of the world around us and in that respect, are very much an asset.

BUT, in gauging progress and forming opinions as a result, it’s a pretty lame idea! Just as you can never walk to the horizon, so can you never attain an ideal golf swing.

Sure you can have a very effective swing, a swing which gets you great results and bring much reward, but it will never be ideal. And yet so many players find themselves wrapped up in the idea of achieving that distant dream. Their language reflects the belief whenever they describe their current work in progress. ‘Ideally, I need the swing to look like X’ or ‘my ideal score is to shoot Y’. More damaging is the fact that no matter what achievement s are secured, if it’s not ‘ideal’, constant self judgement  can  play out as we focus on the gap between what we are and what we believe to be ideal. That gap will always be there, just like the distance to the horizon, no matter how far we walk.

As a mental performance coach, I remind my players that it’s great to have well formed goals, standards to aspire to and to look for ways to improve your current skills base. What isn’t so effective is to set up goals using an ideal as the destination and then striving to get there. You’ll forever come up short in your expectation, opening the door for frustration and disappointment to flourish.

So if you are a reader who believes you’ll be happy when you’ve hit the ideal score or swing the ideal way, perhaps it’s time to revisit your goals and assess where you are, rather than where you want to be.

Is this posting ideal, certainly not, is it good based on my current skill level, I believe so. Will I have improved as a result of constructing this….certainly that’s possible.

So to come full circle, I believe that the ideal golf game remains just an elusive idea. Having said that, for all of you who have attained the ideal game, I’d be delighted to hear your thoughts!

Send any thoughts/feedback to info@progolfmindcoach.co.uk.

Visit www.progolfmindcoach.co.uk for a FREE INNER GAME REPORT

AimPoint Golf Green Mapping

March 23rd, 2010

I’ve received a bunch of questions about how to map the green for a tournament round of golf.  I found this picture on the AimPoint Golf Forum showing what a tour players green mapping might look like if they were using the AimPoint Golf Green Reading method.

AimPoint Golf Green Mapping

AimPoint Golf Green Mapping

Here’s what this shows.  The grid in the background represents distance.  You can also see contour lines under the numbers and arrows.  Contour lines represent areas of equal elevation.  The arrows represent the direction of the slope.  Sometimes, these are referred to as flow lines.  The numbers represent the %slope or the grade.

Without a professional yardage book and caddy, a mapping like this would not really be possible.  However, it should give you some ideas of what it could look like.

2010 AimPoint Golf Green Reading Clinics

March 22nd, 2010

AimPoint Golf Green Reading - Certified Instructor Logo

I have completed scheduling for May and June AimPoint Golf Green Reading Clinics.  The information can be found on the John Graham Golf Forum and by following this link:

2010 May and June AimPoint Golf Clinics

Spots are limited to the first 8 players to register so don’t delay.

Videos, Slideshows and Podcasts by Cincopa Wordpress Plugin